• Aka Guymelef
    Aka Guymelef
    Just might make the CUT
    Comments: 40

    Shame there was no hyper-realistic blood since it was not a haunted game. Also the events not being reported with a stopwatch precision made it really difficult to get the time-frame of events.

    Anyways thanks old man for the read and your insightful comments.

  • Marvelfan211
    Prodigy Pet Gym Leader
    Comments: 130

    Look forward to these every year! I know that these are a ton of work, but this didn’t disappoint.

    Thank you!

  • lichenking
    Comments: 13

    I enjoy these, oh so much.

  • likalaruku
    Completely Useless Now
    Comments: 935

    Imagine Old Man & Halloweenie teaming up to do a dramatic reading of “My Immortal.”

  • Otaku World Order
    Otaku World Order
    Prodigy Pet Gym Leader
    Comments: 124

    Luigi: *Vince McMahon voice* IT WAS-A ME, MARIO! IT WAS-A ME, AAAALL ALONG, MARIO!

    …and then Luigi became Freddy Krueger at the end screen?

    Luigi: *Freddy voice* I’m your boyfriend now, Toadstool.

  • Jon Protagonist
    Jon Protagonist
    Comments: 429

    I actually fell asleep twice while watching this, maybe old man should do relaxation and meditation tapes…but seriously, I kept coming back and finally finished watching. Another great old man Creepypasta!


    Old Man 4LYF!

  • CyborgPrince
    Fighting Steffi Love
    Comments: 172

    So just what was that figure in the window?